 261 votes  | 18% | Daniel Craig - Casino Royale |
| 147 votes | 10% | Joaquin Phoenix - Walk The Line |
| 113 votes | 8% | Christian Bale - Munich and The Prestige |
| 99 votes | 7% | Clive Owen - Children of Men |
| 72 votes | 5% | George Clooney - Syriana |
| 71 votes | 5% | Jake Gyllenhaal - Brokeback Mountain and Jarhead |
| 71 votes | 5% | Aaron Eckhart - Thank You For Smoking |
| 68 votes | 5% | Heath Ledger - Brokeback Mountain |
| 67 votes | 5% | Jack Nicholson - The Departed |
| 59 votes | 4% | David Strathairn - Good Night, and Good Luck |
| 59 votes | 4% | Brandon Routh - Superman Returns |
| 57 votes | 4% | Hugh Jackman - The Prestige |
| 57 votes | 4% | Alan Arkin - Little Miss Sunshine |
| 56 votes | 4% | Kevin Spacey - Superman Returns |
| 54 votes | 4% | Leonardo DiCaprio - The Departed |
| 31 votes | 2% | Joseph Gordon-Levitt - Brick |
| 26 votes | 2% | Matt Damon - The Departed |
| 25 votes | 2% | Steve Coogan - A Cock and Bull Story |
| 24 votes | 2% | Guy Pearce - The Proposition |
| 20 votes | 1% | Mark Wahlberg - The Departed |
| 7 votes | 0% | Danny Huston - The Proposition |
